Can my will be overturned?

Sometimes a will may be successfully challenged in court on the following grounds:

  • That it is invalid (has been signed or witnessed incorrectly).
  • If you had a moral duty to provide for somebody but failed to. This is a claim under the Family Protection Act.
  • If your spouse/partner of at least three years (less if you have had a child together) decides to claim half of the relationship property instead of accepting what was left for them in the will.
  • If you had promised to leave something to somebody on your death for services that they had performed but never updated your will. This is called a testamentary promise.

If you would like further advice about wills, please make an appointment with Malcolm McKenzie or Scott Donaldson.

I don’t get on with one of my children, will he have a claim on my estate when I die?

A child left out of the will could potentially succeed in a claim for maintenance and support under the Family Protection Act.

These claims are all considered separately on their own facts, but the main question is whether or not the deceased had a moral duty to leave something in his/her will to the claimant. The answer to this question is usually determined with reference to factors such as any other competing moral claims, the financial position of the claimant etc.

The view that is most commonly taken by the courts in New Zealand is that parents always have a moral duty to leave something to their biological children in their estate. Bearing this in mind, it is very likely that your child will have a successful Family Protection Act claim on your estate if you decide not to include him/her in your will.

If you would like further advice regarding potential claims on your estate, please make an appointment with Scott Donaldson or Malcolm McKenzie.